13 Reasons Why: TV Show Review (TW: Suicide, Depression, Sexual Assault, Mental Health) Also Spoilers

I finally finished watching 13 Reasons Why on Netflix, and now I am go give my thoughts on the series.

First, let me discuss my views on the book. I felt the book was little over hyped. I did like the ideas the book portrayed such as how bullying leads to suicide, the problem I had with the book was mainly the character of Hannah, and I didn’t connect with her like I did with Clay. I also feel that we didn’t get enough depth about the character on the tapes.

The show, follows the same beats of the show, it starts after the suicide of Hannah Baker, Clay receiving the tapes and starts listening. In the book Clay listens to the tapes in one sitting, but in the show he takes his time to listen to each tape and process the information. That was one of the show main strengths, is not just listening to tapes but also seeing how the school and the other characters on the tapes react to them as well.

Each episode is one tape, that was a big plus because the story could also be more fleshed out. I remember when I first read the book a movie was optioned with Selena Gomez playing Hannah. A movie would not have done the book justice. A TV show made it so much better, and part of me kinda wishes that Hollywood should adapt YA novels into TV series instead of movies.

Another plus was how the characters were a lot more fleshed out, and you them on the tapes and also after the suicide. The characters I felt were more fleshed out were Jessica, Justin and Alex. WIth Jessica especially with what happened to her is who I felt had the most development throughout the show. Justin, while it was a douchy thing that he did , you also see a glimpse into his family life. Alex, is a character who actually really felt bad with what happened to Hannah.. Some other characters such as Marcus and Courtney who didn’t really change in the end and kept conspiring against Clay.

The performances were also very outstanding. Katherine Langford who plays Hannah does an amazing job with the role. She added a lot of depth to the Hannah role, which I always felt was lacking in the book, in which we only see Hannah through the tapes and not her as a person. Another amazing performance is Dylan Minnette who plays Clay is also outstanding in the role, and you really feel for Clay throughout the show. Kate Walsh who plays Hannah’s mother is also great in the role. She does a great job at playing a grief sicken mother dealing with her daughters suicide. Hannah’s parents don’t really play a role in the books so I was glad that it was included in the show. The rest of cast are also very good, and I think it has the best teen cast since Friday Night Lights.

The show also takes a few liberties with the book. It deals with a lawsuit brought forth by Hannah’s parents. Also how Clay listened to the tapes, instead of one night its about a few weeks. Another is how Hannah committed suicide. in the book she overdosed on pills, while in the show it she slit her wrists. Hannah’s suicide could seen as very triggering.

Now to give my thoughts on themes of the show. This show is very split on how it handles suicide and depression. One half says it raises awareness of teen suicide, another side says it trivializes suicide. Some people will say that Hannah’s suicide and the use of the tapes sees it as more of an act of vengeance rather than trying to deal with her mental health problems.

As someone that has dealt with bullying, dealing with depression and has on a few occasions contemplated suicide. I think there is no right or wrong way to write suicide, or mental health stories, and I feel that Hannah’s story shouldn’t have to match my story or anyone else’s. While for some the material the show addresses could be triggering I could fully understand if anyone doesn’t want to watch the show. I kinda wish that both the show and the book did a better job at addressing Hannah’s mental health issues.

In the end, 13 Reasons Why was a very good show that expanded on the book and fleshed out a lot of characters. If they make a second season, I think they will address the lawsuit, maybe Bryce getting arrested for rape, Alex’s suicide attempt and maybe Tyler shooting up the school. I want to see where the story goes.

Season MVP: Katherine Langford, Kate Walsh and Dylan Minnette

Best Episodes: Tape 1, Side A, Tape 6, Side A and Tape 7, Side A.

Season grade: A

Advertisements

7 thoughts on “13 Reasons Why: TV Show Review (TW: Suicide, Depression, Sexual Assault, Mental Health) Also Spoilers

  1. I think that this story is creating a dialogue about something that otherwise is taboo. It’s a hard show to watch and it was a very hard book to read, but they were powerful and meaningful. I liked the added pieces with Hannah parents, I think it helped expand the narrative. There are so many people on my facebook wall that are talking about how terrible the whole idea of this story it, and I honestly think they are missing the point of it. It’s not a story for everyone, and I think that the show itself does a good job in explaining what it is and that there are very triggering aspects of it. I have a lot of feelings about this story and I’m having a hard to writing them down or talking about them in a coherent way

    Liked by 1 person

    • I agree, hopefully the show also removes the stigma surrounding suicide. I would also recommend people to not binge watch the show and let each episode sink in.

      Like

  2. At the beginning I personally thought it romanticized suicide and depression. At the end, however, with the scenes of rape and Hannah committing suicide, I thought those seems kind of straightened it out but it could’ve been better (the beginning). The scenes of rape were so powerful for me and I thought they did a great job showing the emotions the girls had after and during experiencing it. The scene where Hannah commits suicide is very hard to watch which I think is a good thing because it doesn’t shy away from the ugliness. That’s what to me was the best thing about the show; it showed the ugliness of these things. The show itself is good but how people are reacting is not. People, including me, who have experienced some or all of theses things respond to the show very well and they truly want to spread awareness on these topics. People who haven’t experienced these things and/or don’t understand them well are joking about it and romanticizing it. Because of that, I don’t know if making it into a show was the best choice. I know no matter what people will take it the wrong way but the media and Hollywood have such a huge impact on us that I feel like it should’ve been made into something else or stayed as a book.

    Like

    • That is what I liked about the show. It wasn’t afraid to go there in terms of ugliness. Another negative, is how the 13 reasons why memes started, and not understanding how the things you do or say can affect people. Thanks for your response.

      Like

  3. It’s interesting to see the difference between the book and the show. In so many cases the book is usually better, however it sounds as if in this case the show gave the book more justice. I agree that the cast were brilliant, I think they were all really great casting choices and it was a diverse cast as well. I also agree that there is no right/wrong way to right about suicide, it isn’t a pleasant subject (which is why it has been a taboo subject, even now). I think the show is good for people who haven’t experienced any of these things because it educates them. The amount of times I have heard people say that suicide is cowardly and selfish…maybe this show may help change their perception. My main concern is for the people who have experienced these things or are going through these things, this show may be a massive trigger. I have never actually seen such a divided opinion about a show, I think its great people are talking about it, I just think that a lot of people need to proceed with caution. Great post 🙂

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s